A MAGYAR MITTEILUNGEN
TUDOMÁNYOS AKADÉMIA DER
CSILLAGVIZSGÁLÓ STERNWARTE
INTÉZETÉNEK DER UNGARISCHEN AKADEMIE
KÖZLEMÉNYEI DER WISSENSCHAFTEN
BUDAPEST-SZABADSÁGHEGY
Nr. 67.
J. TREMKO
(Astronomical Institute of the Slovak Academy of Sciences
Skalnate Pleso, Czechoslovakia)
THREE COLOUR PHOTOMETRY OF W CVn,
LIGHT CURVE AND PERIOD
BUDAPEST, 1974
ABSTRACT
Three colour photoelectric observations of the variable W CVn
obtained at Konkoly Observatory and at Skalnaté Pleso Observatory
were interpreted. The investigation shows secular change of
the period and a stable light curve. The interstellar absorption in
the direction of the variable is discussed and the absolute magnitude
from the period - luminosity relation was derived. Colour - colour
diagram was constructed and distance of 980 pc for the variable
was determined.
INTRODUCTION
The variable star W CVn belongs to the group of short period
RRab Lyrae-type variables. It was discovered by Ceraski in 1907
on plates made by Blazko /Ceraski 1907/. Later was investigated
by Zinner /1912, 1916/, who discovered an increase in brightness
near the minimum light. She discovered similar increasing in
brightness on the ascending branch and at the phase 0.47P. The
last however changed its place in various cycles. Bugoslawski
/1927/ discovered secondary oscillations on the light curve which
recurred with a period of 0.16057 days. The period of secondary
oscillations was not constant but changed during a cycle of 43.53
days. Photographic observations obtained by Jordan /1929/ and
Robinson /1930/ did not confirm Bugoslawski's conclusions on periodic
secondary oscillations. The light curves derived by both
authors show a conspicuous wave close to the minimum. Similarly
Parenago /1930/ found light curve to be smooth but the brightening
before minimum escaped his attention. In the years 1931 - 1933
Detre /1934/ observed the variable by a Graff wedge photometer
and collected 369 observations. According to his observations
the light curve was smooth and the amplitude of the wave
close to minimum was only 0.02m which differed from the value
0.12m previously found by Jordan /1929/. Later the star was observed
visually or photographically by several observers /Radlova 1934/,
/Kleissen 1938/, /Nachapkin 1940/, /Alania 1954/,
/Strelkova 1960/, /Ahnert 1961/, /Satanova 1961/. Photoelectric
observations are scarce with exception of those obtained at Konkoly
Observatory and Skalnaté Pleso Observatory. Geyer /1961/
obtained UBV photoelectric observations in the range of the phase
0.8P - 0.1P and determined some photometric parameters of the
variable. Sturch /1966/ obtained few UBV photoelectric observations
for the program of colour indices of RR Lyrae-type stars
near minimum light. The latest photoelectric observations are
those obtained by Fitch et al. /1966/. Radial velocity was measured
by Joy /1938/ who found a mean value of RV = + 26 km/sec.
The spectrum of the variable is changing from A6 to F6 and
Preston's quantity Delta S reaches a value of 7 /Woolley et al. 1965/.
OBSERVATIONAL MATERIAL AND REDUCTION
The variable was observed photographically at Konkoly Observatory
in Budapest with 16-inch astrograph by the method of multiple
exposures. Together 288 observations were obtained on the
emulsion "Guilleminot superfulgur". No colour filter was used in
the observations. The photographic material was measured and reduced
by a method widely used also at other observatories. The
brightnesses of the comparison stars were determined by the
comparison with those from North Polar Sequence. The list of the
photographic plates together with further data are given in Table I.
Table I.
J. D. Date Plate N
2429373 20. Apr 1939 H 1106 43
2429401 17. May 1939 H 1147 25
2429401 17. May 1939 H 1148 40
2429401 17/18. May 1939 H 1149 30
2429425 10. June 1939 H 1164 8
2429456 11/12. July 1939 H 1182 60
2429461 16. July 1939 H 1187 27
2433453 20. June 1950 H 2124 25
2434457 21. March 1953 H 2639 30
On the basis of the photographic observations obtained at Konkoly
Observatory four epochs of maxima were derived. They are
included in the Table II. The variable starting from 1959 was intensively
observed photoelectrically at Konkoly Observatory and
at Skalnaté Pleso Observatory. Photoelectric observations in Budapest
were obtained at 24-inch, f/6 reflector with a photoelectric
photometer equipped with 1 P 21 photomultiplier and colour filters
for the photometry in B and V region. Photoelectric observations
of the variable at Skalnaté Pleso Observatory were obtained in two
observational seasons in the years 1963 and 1964 with a photoelectric
photometer attached at 24-inch, f/5.5 reflector. The optical
part of the photometer is equipped with quart Fabry lens
which images the entrance pupil of the telescope into a form of
disc of 4.3 mm in diameter on the photocathode of 1 P 21 photomultiplier.
The photomultiplier was supplied from high voltage
stabilizer NBZ 411 type and an electronic recorder EZ 4 type was
used. The detailed description of the photometer will be done in
forthcoming paper. The set of yellow observations obtained in the
years 1963 - 1964 was supplied with the observations in B and U
colours in the years 1967 and 1968. The standard filters for the
UBV photometry were used. The observations obtained in the instrumental
ubv system were converted into the standard UBV system.
THE PERIOD AND THE LIGHT CURVE
The long series of the observations over 40000 periods made
possible the study of secular changes of the period. In our study
we used the epochs of the maxima published by Detre /1934/ and
mainly observations obtained by Detre and Tremko /this paper/.
From Detre's list /Detre 1934/ we omitted two epochs derived by
Jordan and we computed from Jordan's observations new epochs
of maxima. We omitted from newer observations the epoch of the
maximum derived by Strelkova /1960/, as it shows a very great
residual from the calculated epoch. Probably there is a printing
error in the original paper.
It is remarkable that the elements published by Prager /1930/
include parabolic term for the secular change of the period:
Max_phg = J.D. 2421077.977 + 0.5517622xE - 0.468 10^-9xE^2 /1/
Later Detre /1934/ derived following elements:
Max_hel = J.D. 2421402.4206 + 0.55175981xE /2/
The last computation is that provided by Tsesevich /1966/:
Max_hel = J.D. 2421077.9868 + 0.551758775xE /3/
It is noteworthy the deviation of - 0.008d of the photoelectric epoch
of maximum obtained by Geyer /1961/ from the elements /3/.
Our computations give following elements:
Max_hel = J.D. 2421402.4270 + 0.55175834xE /4/
From the O - C values which are presented in the Table II. and
also from the Fig. 1. it is clearly seen that the period is not constant.
We did not compute the numerical value of the secular
change as it is not clear whether the observed shortening is continuous
or not. The latest observed epoch of the maximum /Fitch
et al. 1966/ confirms our results about secular change of the period
and it is shown that the statement put by Tsesevich /1966/ is
not valid.
Table II.
Max. hel.
E O - C Observer Notes
J.D. 2400000+
15804.828 - 10145 - 0.011 Payne-Gaposchkin pg
20251.450 - 2086 - 0.009 Zinner v
21077.980 - 588 - 0.013 Robinson pg
21402.427 0 000 Blazko v
22081.6350 + 1231 - 0.0065 Jordan pg
22839.7576 + 2605 + 0.0002 Jordan pg
24621.380 + 5834 - 0.005 Parenago pg
26477.504 + 9198 + 0.004 Detre phm
26483.575 + 9209 + 0.005 Detre phm
26488.542 + 9218 + 0.007 Detre phm
26509.508 + 9256 + 0.006 Detre phm
26520.545 + 9276 + 0.008 Detre phm
26540.406 + 9312 + 0.006 Detre phm
26556.407 + 9341 + 0.005 Detre phm
26908.437 + 9979 + 0.013 Detre phm
27260.457 + 10617 + 0.012 Detre phm
27281.426 + 10655 + 0.014 Detre phm
27311.200 + 10709 - 0.007 Radlova v
27543.4939 + 11130 - 0.0034 Kleissen pg
Table II cont.
Max. hel. E O - C Observer Notes
J.D.2400000+
27558.390 + 11157 - 0.005 Soloviev v
27628.468 + 11284 0.000 Soloviev v
27927.516 + 11826 - 0.005 Soloviev v
27955.663 + 11877 + 0.002 Soloviev v
28305.4779 + 12511 + 0.0023 Kleissen pg
29360.431 + 14423 - 0.007 Nachapkin v
29456.447 + 14597 + 0.003 Tremko pg
29461.422 + 14606 + 0.013 Tremko pg
33453.391 + 21841 + 0.010 Tremko pg
34130.377 + 23068 - 0.011 Alania pg
34457.580 + 23661 - 0.001 Tremko pg
35244.3875 + 25087 - 0.0010 Detre pe
35601.394 + 25734 + 0.018 Geyer pg
36232.5813 + 26878 - 0.0024 Geyer pe
36305.4155 + 27010 - 0.0053 Detre pe
36343.4895 + 27079 - 0.0016 Detre pe
36348.4570 + 27088 + 0.0001 Detre pe
36573.5685 + 27496 - 0.0058 Detre pe
36574.6705 + 27498 - 0.0073 Detre pe
36648.6094 + 27632 - 0.0004 Detre pe
36877.601 + 28047 - 0.008 Satanova pg
37025.458 + 28315 - 0.006 Ahnert v
38085.3844 + 30236 - 0.0078 Tremko pe
38448.4414 + 30894 - 0.0078 Tremko pe
38450.6447 + 30898 - 0.0115 Tremko pe
38464.4427 + 30923 - 0.0074 Tremko pe
38497.5455 + 30983 - 0.0101 Tremko pe
38789.977 + 31513 - 0.011 Fitch pe
The period for the interval J.D. 2436305 - J.D. 2438497 was
derived from the photoelectric epochs of the mean light, obtained
by Detre and Tremko /this paper/:
Mean light_hel = J.D. 2436305.3669 + 0.55175735xE /5/
The value of the period is lower as given by the equation /4/.
The epochs of the mean light on the ascending branch were tested
for Blazko effect. The oscillation of the ascending branch is very
small and lies within the limits of the observational errors. The
heights of the maxima, the depths of the minima and the heights
of the hump at the ascending branch also do not show substantial
variation. The presence or the absence of the brightening short
before minimum in the observations of the different observers
can be partly explained by the fact that the range of the brightening
depends on wavelength. The other cause can be longer exposures
of some photographic observations.
The list of the epochs of the maxima, O - C differences and
further data are collected in the Table II. The photoelectric epochs
of the mean light which were used for the computation of
the elements /5/ are in the Table III. and corresponding O - C
differences are plotted on the Fig. 2. The photoelectric observations
obtained at the Skalnaté Pleso Observatory were used for the
construction of the U, B, V, light curves. The variable W CVn
reaches in the V region the maximum brightness 10.065m and in
the minimum light 10.921m. Thus the amplitude of the light changes
is 0.856m which is in good agreement with the value derived
from the photoelectric observations obtained by Detre in Budapest.
M - m value derived from the V light curve is 0.153m and the
hump at the ascending branch is placed at the phase 0.93P. The
hump on the descending branch is located at the phase 0.704P and
it is the most conspicuous in the B colour.
Table III.
Mean light.
hel. E O - C Observer Notes
J. D. 2430000 +
6305.3657 0 - 0.0012 Detre pe
6348.4012 78 - 0.0028 Detre pe
6574.6278 488 + 0.0033 Detre pe
6648.5609 622 + 0.0009 Detre pe
8085.3366 3226 + 0.0005 Tremko pe
8448.3925 3884 + 0.0001 Tremko pe
8450.5987 3888 - 0.0008 Tremko pe
8497.4985 3973 - 0.0004 Tremko pe
The colours in the maximum and in the minimum light are as follows:
U - B B - V
maximum + 0.071 + 0.217
minimum + 0.070 + 0.431
The U - B and B - V data for the minimum light differ only by
0.001 from those published by Sturch /1966/. The our observations
confirm the supposition raised by Sturch /1966/ about the
bluishing of the RR Lyrae-type variables with the P > 0.5d around
the phase 0.7P. The U, B, V light curves are on the Figures 3, 4
and 5.
COLOUR - COLOUR DIAGRAM
Three colour observations of the variable make possible to
construct U - B/B - V diagram. For the construction of the two
colour diagram the data from the Table IV. were used. Two co-
lour diagram for the variable W CVn is rather complicated mainly
owing to the bluer colour around the phase 0.70P. The numbers at
the different points of the two colour diagram on Fig. 6. denote
the phase of the light changes. From the absolute magnitude and
from the photometric data we can determine the distance of the
variable if the interstellar absorption is known. The absolute
magnitude can be derived on the basis of the period - absolute
magnitude relation for the RR Lyrae-type variable with a period
greater than 0.45 days /Woolley et al. 1965/:
M = - 0.10m - 2.5 log P /6/
The distance r then can be derived from the well known equa-
tion:
M_v = m_v + 5 - 5 log r - A_v /7/
The value A_v can be computed from the reddening. According
to Woolley et al. /1965/ the stars with z coordinate higher as 100
parsecs above the galactic plane and in higher galactic latitudes
are reddened by 0.05 x cosec b. The investigation performed by
Sturch /1966/ has shown that the value for the reddening term for
the stars with b > 56 deg is 0.02 x cosec b only, if the excessively
reddened regions in Taurus and Ophiuchus are omitted but the
stars with b > 70 deg are kept. Thus the reddening for the variable
is very low and reaches 0.034m and then the total visual absorption
A_v = 0.103m if we accept the numerical value 3.03 for the ratio of
total to selective absorption /Wickramasinghe N. C. 1967/. The
ratio of total to selective absorption depends on the position of the
star in the Galaxy relative to the Sun and can reach considerable
higher value. Thus the derived total absorption can be considered
as the lowest value. Woolley et al. /1965/ on the basis of the study
of high galactic latitude RR Lyrae-type variables derived following
relation for the determination of the visual absorption:
A_v = 3 [/B/ - /V/ - 0.24] /8/
The mean B - V value for W CVn is 0.374m and according to relation
/8/ the visual absorption reaches 0.402m. Geyer /1961/ has
found that W CVn is reddened by 0.08m which leads to the visual
absorption of 0.244m. The determination of the absorption according
to the method derived by Woolley et al. /1965/ is very sensitive
to the intrinsic colour of the variable. The last term in the
equation /8/ seems to be underestimated and the scatter in the
B - V and mainly in U - B shows /Sturch 1966/ that even this high
latitude sample of RR Lyrae-type variables is in this sense
inhomogeneous. For these reasons we prefer the value of the visual
absorption derived by the first method. As the median visual
brightness V = 10.606m and the absolute visual magnitude computed
from the equation /6/ M_v = + 0.54m, the resulting distance of
the variable derived with the aid of the equation /7/ is 980 pc.
Table IV.
Phase U-B B-V
0.00 +0.071 +0.217
0.10 +0.099 +0.272
0.20 +0.104 +0.334
0.30 +0.155 +0.322
0.40 +0.113 +0.399
0.50 +0.122 +0.420
0.60 +0.022 +0.447
0.65 +0.007 +0.474
0.70 +0.143 +0.367
0.71 +0.157 +0.331
0.73 +0.186 +0.361
0.75 +0.150 +0.409
0.77 +0.113 +0.423
0.87 +0.044 +0.457
0.93 -0.025 +0.254
0.95 +0.012 +0.257
CONCLUSION
The variable star W CVn is RRab type with stable and smooth
light curve excluding the hump on the ascending branch which is
most pronounced in B colour. The period is not constant and the
secular shortening from the earliest observations was found but
Blazko effect is not present. Two colour diagram has a rather
complicated form due to the brightening at the phase 0.7P. Due to
high galactic latitude of the variable the interstellar absorption is
low and the adopted value is 0.10m. We determined the absolute
magnitude which is M_v = + 0.54m from the period - luminosity relation
and after removing the interstellar absorption the distance
of the variable r = 980 pc was found.
The author wishes to thank Prof. Dr. L. Detre for the opportunity
to use the observing material of W CVn obtained at Konkoly
Observatory and for many advices and stimulating discussions.
He is indebted to the members of the staff of the Skalnaté Pleso
observatory mainly to Messrs. L. Petrík, J. Petras and P. Zimmermann
for assistance with 24-inch observing and for the help
with the reductions of the photoelectric observations.
REFERENCES
Ahnert, P., 1961, MVS. 546.
Alania, I. F., 1954, Soviet Astron. Circ. 146.
Bugoslawski, N., 1927, Astron. Nachr. 229, 203.
Ceraski, W., 1907, Astron. Nachr. 176, 109.
Detre, L., 1934, Astron. Nachr. 254, 21.
Fitch, W.S., Wisniewski, V.Z., Johnson, H.L., 1966, Commun.
Lunar and Planet. Obs. 5, 71, 3.
Geyer, E., 1961, Z. Astrophys. 52, 229.
Jordan, F., 1929, Publ. Allegh. Obs., VII, 44.
Joy, A., 1938, Astrophys. J. 88, 108.
Kleissen, E., 1939, Astron. Nachr. 267, 139.
Nachapkin, V.A., 1940, Tadzh. Observ. Circ. 44.
Parenago, P., 1930, Astron. Nachr. 240, 324.
Radlova, L.N., 1934, Len. Bull. 4. 28.
Robinson, V., 1930, Harv. Bull. 876.
Satanova, Eh. A., 1961, Soviet Astron. Circ. 218.
Strelkova, E.P., 1960, Soviet Astron. Circ, 209.
Sturch, C., 1966, Astrophys. J. 143, 774.
Tsesevich, V. P., 1966, Zvezdy Tipa RR Liry, Naukova Dumka,
Kijev.
Wickramasinghe, N.C., 1967, Interstellar grains, Chapman and
Hall, London.
Woolley Sir, R., Harding, G. A., Gassells A. I., Saunders, J.,
1965, Roy. Observ. Bull, 97.
Zinner, E., 1912, Astron. Nachr. 190, 379.
Zinner, E., 1916, Astron. Nachr. 202, 233.
Fig. 1. O - C diagram for the epochs of maxima; squares denote
visual observations, triangles photographic observations,
full dots photometric observations and open circles
photoelectric observations.
Fig. 2. O - C diagram for the epochs of the mean light from the
Table III.
Fig. 3. V photoelectric light curve of W CVn. Full dots represent
four observations, open circles represent two observations.
Fig. 4. B photoelectric light curve of W CVn.
Fig. 5. U photoelectric light curve of W CVn.
Fig. 6. Colour - colour diagram of W CVn. The numbers at the
curve denote the phase.